11 Metacognition: Thinking About My Thinking
"Thinking is what a great many people think they are doing
when they are merely rearranging their prejudices."
—William James
Reflection Purpose Objectives Performance Criteria Discovery Exercise Readings Quiz Resources Exploration Questions Plan Models Critical Thinking Questions Challenge Preparation Problems to Solve My Life Vision
   

REFLECTION

At the heart of this course is the learning process and learning how to learn (the application of metacognition). In this experience, you will use a Learning Journal worksheet, Concept Map, and a Metacognitive Exploration worksheet to help you increase your own metacognition and elevate the level of your thinking and knowledge through guided reflection on learning, learning skills, and critical thinking.

PURPOSE

When we engage in metacognition, thinking about our own thinking, and step back from just doing to determine how and why we actually do what we do, we strengthen all aspects of our own learning and growth.

In several critical ways, this entire course has been about metacognition and increasing and improving your awareness of your own thinking.

A Mother was preparing a baked ham for dinner. Her 10-year old daughter was in the kitchen helping. She watched as her mother prepared the ham, seasoning it and getting it ready for the baking pan. The last thing the mother did before putting the ham in the pan was to cut off about 2 inches from one end. She set this piece aside and then put the ham in the pan and into the oven.

Her daughter asked, “Mom, why did you cut that piece off?”

The mother replied, “That’s how my mother taught me to do it.”

The mother got to thinking and began to wonder. Together, she and her daughter called Grandma and asked her why she cut the bottom off the ham before putting it in the pan. The reply was, “That’s how my mother taught me to do it. But I don’t know why she did that. I’ll give her a call and let you know.”

A while later Grandma called back. The answer, it seems, is that her mother’s only baking pan wasn’t large enough for a full-sized ham, and she had to trim off about 2-inches from the bottom in order to make it fit.

As amusing as the story may be, it truly does illustrate the way most of us tend to sleepwalk through our daily lives, rarely stopping to think about what we’re doing and why. Great-grandma was confronted with a problem, and she used an effective and successful strategy to solve it. Grandma and Mom, on the other hand, merely learned to do what they were shown; they never thought about it more deeply until the daughter stopped everything, asking, “Why?”

This experience take things further than previous experiences in that you’re now ready to literally take your thinking to another level. After all, as you’ve learned by now, when we’re aware of our thinking, we can improve our thinking. In terms of learning skills, metacognition means that:

Additionally, to begin to put it all together,

OBJECTIVES

  1. Strengthen critical thinking skills by focusing on your own thinking process in relation to learning, problem solving, and learning skills.
  2. Strengthen the role methodologies play in improving metacognition.
  3. Prepare for strategically elevating your level of learner knowledge.

PERFORMANCE CRITERIA

If you successfully complete this activity, you will be able to:

From a given learning experience, enhance future performance with this knowledge through metacognition)

DISCOVERY EXERCISE

Metacognitive Exploration: My Learning

  1. Identify something you have learned recently that you can demonstrate through a performance (you can show that you know it). It must be, at a minimum, at Level 2: Conceptual Understanding in the Levels of Learner Knowledge. Note: Take some time to reflect on the learning you want to select. It should be robust enough that it can be taught to someone else and important enough that others would need to learn it as well.
  2. Make an entry in your Assessment Journal about what you learned, responding to the Learning Journal prompts below. Use the subject, "I Learned..." for this entry.
  3. Now complete a second entry in your Assessment Journal, this time responding to the Metacognitive Exploration prompts, shown below. Do this in a REPLY to your previous post ("I Learned..."). You are encouraged to work in something like Notepad and then to simply copy and paste your finished work from there. The longer a post you work on, the more you should consider creating the post off-line, where you can save it. It is extremely frustrating to have your connection timeout an hour into writing a long post...)
  4. Answer the Exploration Questions.

Learning Journal Prompts

Focus:  

What I learned:  

What triggered my learning?  

How do I know I've learned it? (Validate your learning.)  

Why is it important?  

How will I apply my new knowledge now?  

How can I apply my learning in the future? 

Metacognitive Exploration Prompts

What I learned (describe what you learned and a typical performance that demonstrates the learning, Experience 1)   

My current level of learning (use the Levels of Learner Knowledge, Experiences 2 & 11)   

How I know that’s the level of my learning
(use the Levels of Learner Knowledge, Experiences 2 & 11)   

Learning skills I use when I demonstrate or apply my learning (use the Classification of Learning Skills)

   Cognitive domain:  

   Affective domain:   

   Social domain:  

Draft a “Why?” statement (explain to a learner why he or she should want or need to learn this)
  

How I would teach it to someone else (create a methodology, Experiences 2, 4, 6, 9, & 10)  

Three critical thinking or inquiry questions 
(questions to help a new learner explore or transfer learning)  

   Question 1:   
   Answer:   

   Question 2:   
   Answer:   

   Question 3:   
   Answer:  

READINGS

RESOURCES

EXPLORATION QUESTIONS

When you're ready, click to answer these questions online.

  1. When do things click in your mind and become easy to learn?
  2. What is the role of thinking in learning?
  3. What is the role of thinking about thinking?
  4. What is the role of reflection in metacognition?

PLAN

  1. Review the Concept Map of a Concept Map (Model 1)
  2. Study the Model Concept Map (Model 2)
  3. Working in your neighborhoods, each individual should post a concept map for one of the following concepts: Learning to Learn or Creating Self-Growth. You are free to use whatever software or approach you like for creating your concept map, as long as it can be posted in a format that is readily viewable by your fellow teammates (you may use an attachment rather than posting it inline in your post, if you prefer). Share your concept map on the topic, "Concept Maps". (Here are the direct links for that topic in each neighborhood:  1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    9    10 )
  4. Individually answer the Critical Thinking Questions

MODELS

CRITICAL THINKING QUESTIONS

When you're ready, answer the following questions in the Critical Thinking Questions forum. The questions are posted there as well.  1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    9    10 

  1.  For each of the nine steps in the Elevating Knowledge Methodology, identify a specific thinking skill from the Classification of Learning Skills that would be used to perform that step.

  2. Are all the thinking skills from the cognitive domain? Explain your answer. If you answered "No," what are some examples of thinking skills from other domains?

  3. What role does a methodology play in increasing metacognition about a specific performance?

  4. How does concept mapping improve your metacognition?

  5. What role does generalizing play in the learning process? Provide at least two reasons why that role is important.

CHALLENGE

Your challenge is to learn to take previous learning (such as you documented in the Discovery Section section of this experience) and actually raise the level of your thinking, knowledge, and learning.

PREPARATION

Elevating your level of learning: Upgrading your answers to Critical Thinking Questions

Identify 5 of your responses to Critical Thinking Questions that you feel illustrate your best work. The answers you select should come from the first 10 experience in this course and must all be from different experiences (i.e., no more than one answer from any experience). Locate, copy, and paste the questions and your responses to them into a working document (Notepad or something similar). You will now ELEVATE the level of your responses, thereby elevating your learning!

PROBLEMS TO SOLVE

Using what you have learned from the Methodology for Elevating Knowledge, you will create a SINGLE forum post that responds to the following prompts for EACH Critical Thinking Response you selected. This will be a long post and have 5 major 'chunks', one for each of the CTQ responses you selected. (You are strongly advised to do your work offline, since the post will be so long and detailed.)

Share your post in the forum, "Elevating My Critical Thinking."

A sample response from a previous student for a single Critical Thinking Question follows the prompts.

Elevating My Critical Thinking Prompts

Experience # and Critical Thinking Question (the question itself):

Previous answer:

* New answer:

How can what you learned in answering this question be applied to a different situation to produce value? (To answer this, name a new situation where you can apply this knowledge in your professional, personal, or educational life and describe how you can apply this learning — understanding — to produce value in this new situation. This is called, "contextualizing your knowledge.")

List 4 additional (and meaningful) situations/contexts where your learning can be applied.

Assume you're teaching someone else what you learned here. What 3 tips would you offer them to help them apply their knowledge effectively?


* Make sure your new answer addresses the complete question (not just your surface or initial interpretation). Each answer should be factual (where possible) and convincing to others. This means that you should provide supporting evidence whenever possible (demonstrating facts) and make a reasonable and clear explanation that others can follow.


Sample Student Response to a SINGLE Critical Thinking Question

Experience 11, Question 2. For each step in the Elevating Knowledge Methodology, what would be an example of a thinking skill used to perform that step?

Previous answer:

1 = identifying inconsistencies, 2 = recognizing patterns, 3 = comparing differences, 4 = bounding, 5 = contextualizing, 6 = exemplifying, 7 = divergent thinking, 8 = lateral thinking, 9 = generalizing

New answer:

The following table shows each step of the methodology, along with the correlated learning skill:

Step Explanation Level Explanation Learning Skill
1 Informational base 1 Establish and solidify an informational base. Identifying Inconsistencies
2 Prior knowledge 2 Identify the cornerstones for the knowledge. Knowledge is built upon a foundation of prior knowledge. Recognizing Patterns
3 Inquiry questions 2 Identify the key inquiry questions for comprehension and key issues for constructing the knowledge. Comparing Differences
4 Test conditions 2 With the framework in place, test the conditions of the structure; use critical thinking to explore the assumptions or logic of the knowledge model. Bounding
5 Familiar context low 3 Transfer and apply the knowledge to a familiar context to enrich understanding. Contextualizing
6 Similar context low 3 Transfer and apply the knowledge to another context that is similar. Exemplifying
7 Distant context 3 Transfer and apply the knowledge to a context that is some distance from the original context. Divergent Thinking
8 Unfamiliar context 3 Transfer and apply the knowledge in a totally unfamiliar context with the teacher acting as consultant. Lateral Thinking
9 Generalize 4 Independently make a generalization of the new knowledge. Generalizing

The low-level knowledge, i.e., steps 1 & 2, correlate with information processing learning skills. Steps 3 – 5 seem to align best with learning skills related to constructing understanding (which is what we're actually doing!). Steps 6 – 9 align with learning skills concerned with applying knowledge.

How can what you learned in answering this question be applied to a different situation to produce value? (To answer this, name a new situation where you can apply this knowledge in your professional, personal, or educational life and describe how you can apply this learning — understanding — to produce value in this new situation. This is called, "contextualizing your knowledge.")

When working on constructing knowledge, whether in school or at work, and I get confused or frustrated, I can identify where in the methodology I am (and I most often get stuck at Step 7, Distant context) and look in the classification for a learning skill that I'm not really using. By concentrating on using it, I can help myself over that hurdle (really not being used as much as you actually could to strengthen current learning at that specific step. Even just looking at the Skill Cluster for that step, "Being Creative" gives me ideas...other skills there are challenging assumptions and transforming images. This keeps me from just staring at a problem, feeling stuck. It gives me alternate ways of approaching the problem or thinking of it. That helps a lot!

List 4 additional (and meaningful) situations/contexts where your learning can be applied.

The classification of learning skills are used during problem solving process, preparation methodology, reading methodology, and during the personal development methodology (make sure to consider the affective domain with this methodology also). 

Assume you're teaching someone else what you learned here. What 3 tips would you offer them to help them apply their knowledge effectively?

The learner, who is more in tune with the classification can use the classification in real time to constantly find the opportunities for learner performance by predicting which skills that would be used. Stop and take out 5 minutes when things are going slowly to investigate. At the end of the process, pick an appropriate skill to self-assess with regard to the performance.

MY LIFE VISION

Seeing Myself through Three Learning Skills

Remember that in terms of learning skills, metacognition means becoming aware of our thinking (cognitive domain), our emotional reactions and values (affective domain), and our interactions with others (social domain).

In this installment of My Life Vision, you get to select three learning skills (one from each domain) that are meaningful to you and illustrate aspects of your personality. For each, do a little self-exploration and write a meaningful paragraph about that aspect of yourself. This is all about self-awareness; turn the light on yourself and have fun.

You are required to upload the file you create and it must be at least 2 pages in length. Follow the prompts as given on the assignment page.